India Block 10: Goodbye Mother India

March 2, 2012

As my driver approached the airport, there was a gorgeous sunset across the skyline dotted with black outlines of palms.  Mother India’s breath-taking “good-bye” to me, I thought.  My elective month in India came to a close after what seemed like more than a month of rich experiences.

Unfortunately there was less time for writing and reflection that I imagined.  My days were packed with clinical work and socializing.  My weekends were spent traveling to explore a tiny fraction of the overwhelming countryside.  I never even got close to the Taj Mahal.  India is a huge country that offers far more than one can experience in a lifetime, let alone a month.

While I barely scraped the surface, my clinical experiences proved far more rewarding that I had hoped. I’m now struggling to give people the 60-second version of my trip that most Americans have time and desire to hear (and feeling very impressed by my dedicated blog reader friends).

I feel as if I am bringing back far more than I gave India, and deeply appreciate the medical university and patients who invited me into their space. Isolated by my inability to speak the local language or understand customs, I was hardly able to function like a doctor. Rather, I was a “sponge” attaching myself to the Indian physicians who graciously translated and answered my questions.

My patient relationships consisted of observation, physical exams and appreciation of abnormal findings I rarely see in the USA, exchanging facial expressions and eye contact, and rarely assisting with a minor procedure.  I hardly did anything to benefit a patient directly.  So at times I struggled with feeling like a “medical tourist.”

One month is too short.  At least my medical university has a growing connection with the institution (of which visiting elective students, such as myself, are only a small part).  I still dream of making permanent connections abroad, and at least I’ve finally made my first global family physician friendships during this trip.

Most importantly, I was inspired by the medical differences and especially the dedicated servitude of the Indian physicians amidst overwhelming need and limited resources.  They face this challenge daily without reward or recognition. If I start to feel entitled to something easier in my career, my Indian memories will remind me a doctor’s mission is a healing service.


India Block 10: Clinical Snapshots

February 28, 2012

India can’t be summarized with a few words or photographs.  My visual records make India seem delightful, full of color and discoveries.  Yet, it’s inherently more challenging to capture and share the difficult moments that remain so strongly ingrained in my mind.  Here are a few “snapshots” of influential clinical moments.

* * *

Read the rest of this entry »


India Block 10: House Visits

February 23, 2012

Normally stethoscopes and motorcycles do not mix.  However, when Indian family doctors make house calls to the slums, the combination is necessary.  How else would one venture into the narrow maze-like paths of the slums?

“Are you comfortable with riding motorcycles?” Dr. S, my physician mentor, asked.

“More or less,” I said, “it’s been a while…”  My inexperience showed as I fumbled to fasten my helmet, and awkwardly shifted my balance to saddle the seat.  “Just relax and hold on,” was his advice.

We were off into the streets of India, full of oxen pulling carts, pedestrians and many other vehicles whizzing in all directions and speaking an intense Morse-code-like language of horn taps and blows.  I felt my awareness of the dangers making me more alive.

The turn off the main road began a winding journey into the slums.  It would be unfair to call the passageways “roads” since they were barely wide enough for us to pass.  I could hardly believe my driver’s skill, and my own trust.  I squeezed my feet closer to the vehicle.  The walls were painted light blue with reflected sunlight, and for a moment I imagined parting clouds.

We were on our way to make a house visit to see Bushpa, a woman only a few years older than my mother with severe hypertension (high blood pressure) who had suffered a paralyzing stroke.  She was unable to come to the clinic due to her paralysis.  To make matters more complicated her only living family was a grandson who had a demanding work schedule and was unable to accompany her to the doctor.

These narrow alleys led us to a new land of box houses, each no larger than my bathroom in the USA. Goats and pigs were grazing at garbage-lined open sewage.  Cow dung was drying in a spotted pattern on the side of a house, “for fuel” the doctor explained.

We had barely approached when a group of women called to us.  “She’s telling me about a boy who I saw last time with bow legs,” Dr. S translated. They had a passionate interchange, and he explained that he treated this boy for rickets, but arranged a subsidized appointment for him to be seen by orthopedic specialists.  The women explained why the child couldn’t keep his appointment due to a nose-piercing ceremony.

“These are complicated family issues you can’t understand,” Dr. S told me. “It’s easy for you or I to get angry because the patient has ignored us.  We have different priorities. We can’t imagine the significance of family traditions here.”

After having moved forward only about ten feet, a young woman emerged from her box, holding a medical chart (which patients keep in India).  Dr. S stopped immediately, and the first thing I noticed was her pleasant smile as she spoke.

“You would imagine she’s telling me some good news by the way she smiles, right?” Dr S remarked.  As it turns out, she was a young uncontrolled diabetic who had been absent from clinic for months.  “She’s telling me that she’s been unable to come because of her husband’s alcoholism.  He’s using all their money for drinking and beating her every night.” He glanced at her medical chart and pointed to a blood sugar from her last visit in the 300’s.  He encouraged her to come to clinic the next day.

A tearful elderly woman approaches.  Without pause, the Dr. S tells me, “This woman has lost her husband one month ago.”  She spoke to us with trickling tears, and Dr. S put his hand on her shoulder. I didn’t even need translation to understand the comfort that had been given.

We moved forward, past a young by who smiled and waves. Dr. S told me he was admitted last month to the hospital for a severe asthma attack.  “Look, he’s doing much better now!”   And then we passed a man with a cloth over the side of his face.  “That man was discharged yesterday after we drained his facial abscess.  He’s looking much better too.”

Finally we arrived at Bushpa’s house!  We came for one patient, but we had already seen five.  It seemed everyone welcomed Dr. S.  Bushpa was no exception, even dragging herself to the door by cane. “Don’t help her too much,” Dr. S warns, “we need to see how she is doing when she’s alone.”

I took her blood pressure- 144/70.  Dr. S knew her well, and seemed satisfied by this.  He checked her plastic bag containing multiple medications.  As we left, she seemed to be pleading as she asked Dr. S to “please come back and see me again soon.”

Before we get back to the hospital, Dr. S began to tell me Bushpa’s complicated history.  Although as we passed several more people, Bushpa’s tale became interspersed with fragments from other patients.  I was in awe that Dr. S knew so many stories.

Dr. S explained the value of house visits, noting “we can’t expect patients to come find us if they don’t see us.  These are people who will never go to see a doctor if you waited for them.”  I have only one thought, “I want to be like this doctor!”  But how can it be done in the USA?

The next morning at diabetic group clinic, I was surprised to see the young woman with the beautiful smile.  To everyone else, she was just another patient in the room.  For me, she was a miracle, one of the unexpected fruits from my previous afternoon.


India Block 10: First Day Prenatal Care

February 2, 2012

My first few days in India are best described as “sensory overload.” First, there are the colors, everything from the dingiest black to the brightest gold. Then there is the warmth, spicy foods, smells, horns, crowds, garbage & beauty everywhere I look. And finally, the chaos and disorganization. Nothing is quite as expected, which can drive someone mad when she isn’t used to it. Patience and flexibility are not virtues in India, but absolute necessities! Fortunately I cultivated a lot of this in Peace Corps.

However, the population is so condensed and I am such an outsider, that this experience feels much more intense than any other developing country I’ve visited. I can’t even begin to put it all into words, and I’m already sorry that there is so much I won’t be able to share with you.

But, I’ll just begin by sharing something about today. My first clinical posting isn’t what I expected, but it’s absolutely perfect for me. I am at a low cost unit, which is a small division of the hospital that provides subsidized care to the poorest Indians. It is akin to a Federally Qualified Health Center (FQHC) in the USA, although the subsidies are from private donations, rather than the government.

My experience has already exceeded my expectations because the entire low cost unit is run by family physicians, many of whom were trained in the USA.  I didn’t expect to meet any family physicians because I was told that India does not recognize the specialty, but the people I met are full spectrum family doctors in the truest sense, and all identify themselves that way.

I was overjoyed to see "Family Medicine" as I approached the director's office on my first day. He explained that India doesn't officially accredit family doctors (yet), but they are hoping to be pioneers of this discipline in India.

I spent the whole morning doing prenatal care with two female doctors. I learned so many interesting things during this experience, but perhaps the most interesting was that dating the pregnancies was extremely problematic. The doctors had an excellent ultrasound machine and were highly skilled. However, most of the poor women failed to keep track of menstrual cycles, nor realize they were pregnant.

Many of them presented in the 2nd and even 3rd trimester, a time when dating isn’t very accurate. Some women in the USA also don’t realize they are pregnant until late, however this is the exception. At the clinic this morning, it seemed to be the norm. This creates many problems, not the least of which is inability to provide effective prenatal care.

Also, it is a national law that sex cannot be revealed due to the high amount of female infanticide. All the women had to sign special documents saying that we had not revealed the sex.

I couldn’t help but think about the contrast between American patients and the Indian women I saw today.  The Indian women were much more poorly nourished than any American woman I have seen. For example, “obesity ” is defined as BMI>27 (not 30 like the USA). The norm for birth weight at this hospital is around 5 lbs. The maternal mortality is extremely high in India.

The chart about fundal heights for prenatal exams. I was struck by how much smaller Indian babies are than US babies. The average birthweight here is 5.5lb.

I couldn’t help but feel depressed about the terrible allocation of resources. In the USA women are extremely educated and concerned about pregnancy, and wealthy enough to consume prenatal vitamins, take medications, try various types of diets, eat supplemented food, etc. Why do American woman (who are better nourished and healthy to begin with) use so many vitamins which would be better utilized on the women I met today?


India Block 10: Global Health

January 29, 2012

Exciting news! In late November I was chosen for a Global Health Grant offered my university, so my next 4-week elective will be abroad.  I am leaving tonight to travel farther than I have ever traveled before.

About $20 in Indian Rupees.

India here I come!  I hoped to take advantage of opportunities to go abroad during my 4th year of medical school.  Now I am about to visit a country I have deeply admired since childhood.

My first  memory of Indian culture was attending an Indian dance festival when I was in the 2nd grade.  The spicy smells, crowds and exotic music drew me in.  The brilliant stories of romance unfolded with hand gestures accented by pleated fabric, and more shiny gold than I had ever seen before.

Since then, I’ve had friends and colleagues from India, parents and relatives who traveled to India, and many delicious Indian meals (some I even cooked myself).  In fact, let’s check out my spice rack right now…

Indian spices alongside “Spanish Paprika” and “Southwest Rub,” a beautiful example of our globalized world.  Medicine is participating in this type of globalization too, a deluge of diseases and treatment styles spice up the science.  I’m proud that my school believes global experience is important for future physicians. So do a growing number of residency programs who I noticed advertising “global health” as part of their curriculum.

Most people have asked me some version of: “Do you know what you’ll actually be doing?!”   Not exactly.  I was told I would be given “postings” in “Community Health” (India’s version of “Family Medicine”) and “Infectious Disease.”  As a total outsider, I certainly don’t expect to be very useful, but I’ll have lots of humility, gratitude and compassion, and I’ll do what medical students do best, be a sponge.

For the last week, I’ve mainly been focussing on preparation.  I read about India.  I communicated with Indians. I spent an hour gawking at Google Earth (after which I felt like a speck of dust in the universe).  I started my antimalarial prophylaxis. And now it’s time to pack… packing LIGHT… a true art form!

What's in my bag for this global health trip?


Uganda

May 8, 2011

Hujambo! This is the story of my trip to Uganda, which actually begins long before Uganda. About four years-ago, I returned from Peace Corps and my dad began traveling to accredit international laboratories as part of his work as a pathologist.  He invited me to join him again and again, and as the lives of two busy adults often interplay, we found no synchronicity.  That was… until my recent 3-week vacation between my 3rd and 4th year of medical school.

My dad will tell it another way.  He’ll say that he took my brother to Kenya last year, so he had to take me to Uganda this year.  But truth be told, it had nothing to do with the destination or sibling equality.  It was pure chance of timing, but after four years of failed timing, I’m glad it finally came to be.  After all, didn’t I (his future physician child and returned Peace Corps Volunteer) deserve to share the family experience of international medical work?

The saddest part of our trip to Africa was the beginning.  My dad and I found out days before leaving the country that he had $3,000 stolen by an African internet scammer.  I won’t go into details, but this is the type of problem that Africa is well known for, unfortunately. And to make matters worse, the day before we left the country there were violent riots in our destination city. Five Ugandans were killed and flights were cancelled.

As we left the USA, I wasn’t sure what was awaiting me in Uganda. After a long 13-hour sleepless flight, I saw my first glimpse of Africa, the yellow, dusty landscape of Addis Ababba Ethiopia. Our second flight took us to Uganda, with contrasting lush green hills.  We flew down over Lake Victoria, and I had a wonderful view.  I was expecting clouds because it was “rainy season,” but all I saw was gorgeous sunshine with cool breeze.

There was no difficulty getting visas, or getting to the hotel.  And on our way into town I saw one of the most impressive things of my whole trip to Africa – a guy with about 50 live chickens driving a motorcycle!  The chickens were flapping, giving the impression that the “chicken-cycle” was a live creature, half human and half wings.

We hired a driver named Mousa (pronounced “Moose- ah”) to take us around Kampala.  We stopped at a craft market, supermarket, the parliament, Makarere University and “Old Kampala” with its impressive Gadaffi Mosque.  We didn’t go inside since Bin Laden had just been killed.  However, the atmosphere in Kampala seemed too caught up in its own political unrest to care much about Bin Laden.

The next day I accompanied my dad to the research laboratory. The political situation did not deter us from the trip’s purpose.  The lab was a research laboratory dedicated to HIV, and their biggest project was developing an HIV vaccine currently in stage 1 trial.  The director told me he feels in about 15 years we’ll probably have an effective HIV vaccine, at least for the African strain of HIV.

Amazing, isn’t it?  All the work that goes into developing a successful vaccine is astounding – freezers, energy to store specimens, all the specimens extracted by hands, volunteer patients, years of dedication, etc.  To respect all these efforts we ought to feel honored as patients able to get annual flu shots (and other vaccines).

Yet I know so many people who don’t even make the effort to get vaccinated.  Do it!  Vaccines are miraculous, in fact so miraculous that I might even overlook the cost of my recent vaccines for Uganda (which I recently discovered is not covered by my insurance).

I observed my dad while he did his work, and asked lots of questions about the research.  Then, I got my own personal tour of Makarere University medical school and public hospital. It felt similar to my experiences touring the public hospital in the Dominican Republic.  Room after room of patients overflowing onto the floors, warm spaces with scarce plumbing, doctors and medical supplies.  The main difference were individual specialty departments for diseases common in Africa like “Sickle-Cell Disease” and “Burkitt’s Lymphoma.”

Uganda met my expectations as a developing country in political turmoil, with very little tourism.  However, I didn’t expect to love the culture as much as I did, especially after having $3,000 stolen.  Yet my experience with Ugandans was friendly and polite, and I loved our conversations.  I felt it was easy to ask people about everything, and they seemed excited to tell me about their birds, politics, weddings, lack of cemeteries, etc.

Ugandan cuisine was delicious – soups, goat stew, mashed plantains, peanut butter sauce and tropical fruits.  I tried grasshoppers and even those were delicious.  Seriously- imagine buttery-cheesy pop corn.

And after the inspection was over, dad and I went on a safari to the national parks, overflowing with animals which are crowded into small confines by the growing population.  Villages shared fence-less borders with the land that was once all home to elephants and lions.  And chimpanzees watched me as intently as I watched them.

I found myself excited by the natural beauty, and the birth-land to humanity. I want to go back, and maybe somebody as a physician I will.  After all, it seemed like every American we met had some connection to health care or public health projects.


La Republica Dominicana

July 7, 2009

Sweat drips down the side of my face.  I do not move, even though it tickles.  I am wearing plastic gloves covered with starchy-feeling powder.  I am in a cement box with a tin roof, and surrounded on all sides by mint green walls.  This is not a clinic, but momentarily I am trying to transform it into one.  I have my stethoscope draped across my shoulders, a sign of my medical training (they told us that white coats would be much too intimidating).

So instead of the usual outfit and setting, I am focusing on acting kind and treating my patient with a lot of respect, something I know is lacking at the other state and rural clinics.  I leave the room to let her undress and I knock before I come in.  I can tell she is not used to this.  In my best Spanish I try to gently explain everything, like my OBGYN at home.  “Have you had a pap smear before?” “I’m going to tell you what I’m doing, and it won’t hurt.  Just pressure.”  After all this comes the moment when I can’t wipe my own sweat.

I lean over her with the plastic gloves and jelly covered fingers holding a disposable speculum.  She’s on a camping cot, a poor stand-in for a hospital bed.  The cot hovers about a foot off the floor, so I am leaning and squatting.  I have a small flashlight to guide me, and the presence of a 4th year medical student, Phil, who is a wonderful teacher.  She’s very matter-of-fact without any complaints while I’m doing her pap smear.  Three brushes from different areas that I smear in order on a glass slide.  The final brush must go into the cervical opening.  Then, I’m done.  I carefully move the brushes and glass slide.

I leave the room quickly- to spray the slide with hairspray.  This final step is oddly different from the USA where pap smears usually go in liquid preservative.  But my first pap smears are in this hot, mint green world, where I’m not only struggling to focus on my new skills. I am also trying to ignore my sweat, my mosquito bites and stomach cramps.

In these conditions, I’ve had many firsts in medicine.  My first time removing stitches from a motorcycle accident victim.  My first time unwrapping a finger that’s been half-way severed across the knuckle with a machete knife.  We examine it and confirm that the extensor digitorum tendon has been severed. My first time pulling tobacco out of wounds.  My first time hearing murmurs and Mobitz Type I.  My first positive shifting-dullness test.  My first time watching teeth being pulled.  My first time interviewing patients in Spanish.  It’s exciting and sometimes scary.

Most of the children have never been to doctors like us.  Our digital thermometers, metal odoscopes and stethoscopes seem like needles to them, and I flinch as mom has to hold down her screaming child so I can confirm an ear infection or skin rash.  I am trying to comfort- I show them the light, I do it to myself and to mom.  I tell them it won’t hurt, but to no avail.  To them it’s still a scary needle-like metallic glean.

The best part of living with my patients in a small community is seeing them often.  There is a sweet guy who was concerned about his prostate- now he’s smiling and hugging me on the street.  There is a little boy who I made cry, so hard that he vomited.  Now he’s started antibiotics and he’s playing, and waving at me as if to say, “Thanks, I forgive you for that torture.”  My host sister’s friend had her tooth pulled and she says she feels so much better now.  Overall so many people look familiar- they smile at me, and I know I have seen them in clinic.  I can’t remember all the details, but I do know the faces, and in this small town, it’s easy to feel that the patient-doctor relationship is more than a 30-minute visit.

As I get ready for my last days in Sabana Rey, what I have come to love most about this community is what I originally feared the most.  It is the conditions of poverty that force everyone to be so much closer than is comfortable in the USA.  I have experienced closeness here like I only share with my husband at home.  For example, my bed in the Dominican Republic is a full-size bed, and it fits three volunteers sideways.  What I feared would be uncomfortable has now become a source of great enjoyment.  I love sharing this bedtime where we talk about everything- whatever is on our hearts after a challenging day.  We don’t hide anything, and I feel so comforted and protected.

My host family and many of my patients in clinic have told me that they love me, which are words rarely used in the USA.  Little children hold my hands, and sit on my lap.  It makes me want to share more closeness with my patients, my family, and my friends.  Why is it less awkward to share so many close moments with people in the Dominican Republic who I barely know- than back at home with people to whom I consider myself close?

I wonder how I can bring some of this back in a culture, a city and a profession that doesn’t encourage or allow a lot of time for real human relationships.  Volunteering in Sabana Rey has given me a lot of new things to ponder mixed with new knowledge.  As I prepare to start my second year in a few weeks, I look forward to the fond medical and community experiences that I will bring with me.


Thinking About Summer Already

November 9, 2008

Yesterday I had a phone interview to volunteer with a medical program in “campos” (villages) in rural Dominican Republic.  I want to go abroad this summer.  I hope to observe a low-cost healthcare operation and see how people are served by a service organization.  Not to mention it would be wonderful to learn some medical Spanish (a must to assist medically underserved populations in the USA).

This program sounds quite interesting, especially since I would stay with a host family and be isolated from phone or internet.  The program dates span over Ben and my first anniversary, so that would be challenging.  But I talked to Ben and he was not discouraged.  I get really excited to think about clinical experiences right now- I need to be reminded about why I am doing this.

Most of my days at school are spent looking at molecules and diagrams, and having information “poured” onto me.  Each day, I become aware of some other tiny process in the body.  Certain mysterious elements have started to become clearer.

 

I wonder what it will be like when I can look at others and myself and envision what is going on inside their bodies.  For example, right now, when I look at my torso, I can kind of imagine what things inside look like and where they go.  After a few months, I should be able to name, feel, envision, know the color and texture, and examine everything.  My torso will never be the same again after that.  Meanwhile, time is flying so fast, I can’t help thinking about summer break already.

 


My First Patient

August 18, 2008

I will always consider Irinka* to be my first patient.  Her mother Nadia* came to me in tears (which was unusual because Ukrainian women rarely cried, especially in front of strangers).  She explained the situation.  Her daughter was 8-years-old, and over the past two years had developed a knot in her upper spine.  She was in chronic pain, and slowly losing movement in her arm.  She couldn’t afford to pay for care, but the doctors in Lviv had suggested she contact a hospital in Warsaw, Poland where she might receive free care since Irinka was a child.

Nadia made a great effort to obtain the proper visas to take Irinka to the hospital there, and the Warsaw clinic agreed to perform an MRI free of charge.  The results clearly showed a tumor, however language barriers and time limitations prevented further discussion with the Warsaw doctors.

When they returned to Lviv, the doctors explained that they were afraid to operate because they could not tell if the tumor was cancerous, and if it was, it could metastasize quickly and be fatal.  Additionally, the location of the tumor, between C3-C4, was near the brain stem and the doctors felt it was too risky for their facilities.

Nadia did not know what to do next.  She had been agonizing over her daughter’s condition constantly, and was not able to receive any response from the Lviv Red Cross.  After hearing her story, I met Irinka.  She seemed to be a healthy 8-year-old who hid under a baseball cap.  She was blonde with freckles, and practiced a couple English phrases she knew.  She drew me a beautiful picture of a princess.

I was compelled to try to help her even though I didn’t understand anything about her situation myself.  Nadia provided me with her MRI scans, which looked like an abstract painting at the time.  I spent a lot of time on my town’s slow internet connection trying to find information about spinal tumors.

I e-mailed an organization which assists American children with spinal tumors, and eventually found the e-mail address for a specialist from John Hopkins.  I didn’t think anybody would respond to my e-mails, but they responded almost instantly.  The specialist wanted to see the MRI images.  The director of the organization wrote a heartfelt message that I later translated out-loud for Irinka’s mother.  Nadia cried again.

Over the months to follow many events occurred.  First, upon receipt of the MRI images, the US doctor quickly affirmed that Irinka’s tumor was “osteoid osteoma” (a rare bone growth that is not cancerous).  The location made the surgery tricky, but he was confident that it did not require great expertise.  With the help of Ukrainian Peace Corps doctors, I was able to locate a clinic in western Ukraine that would perform the surgery, and I gave the information to Dana.  I am still not sure how she collected funds for the operation, but Irinka finally had her surgery in April 2007, after I had already left Ukraine.

I wonder what would have happened to this young girl if Nadia and I had never met.  Would Irinka still be in pain?  I think of all those people in the world who have chronic diseases, for whom nobody is there to provide a clear answer or care.  In Ukraine (and in many places) there are countless people who cannot get care- who die of cancer without ever knowing what was wrong with them.  What a huge difference it made to have people offer free scans, explanations, and eventually surgical expertise.  For Irinka, it was the difference of a slow, painful disability, and a normal life.

Soon after meeting Irinka, a father came to me to ask about Cochlear implants for his deaf daughter, Olessya*. She became the first girl in my Ukrainian town to get the implants, and he has written me descriptive letters overjoyed at the number of words she has learned.

Modern medicine is miraculous- the deaf can hear, and suffering is healed.  And when they cannot be, even the understanding of disease (insightful communication and compassion from others) can relieve grief and suffering.  In the course of a lifetime, we all will experience suffering and death.  But, Irinka was an inspiration to me that least everybody should be able to understand their condition and avoid unnecessary additional suffering and disability.

*names have been changed


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.